BEST

15.  Most lesser-known companies
14.  USAA
13.  Liberty Mutual
12.  AAA
11.  Travelers

SOMEWHAT FAIR

10. American Family
9.   Esurance
8.   Allstate
7.   Safeco
6.   Progressive
5.   Nationwide
4.   Farmers

WORST

3.  Nevada General
2.  Geico
1.  State Farm